Leaked Fico Document – Reasoning Codes

- Nov 5, 2018 credit, Credit Scores2 comments

Which Factors Does Fico Use To Calculate Your Credit Score

In this day in age, where transparency is at a very high level, it may sound very shocking to you, but the formula for the Fico scoring model (a scoring model which is used in 90% of mortgage-lending decisions) is still 100% confidential.

Consumers have very little insight into what factors are used to determine their Fico score. Fico only revealed the general 5 big factors which you can read more about here.

Reasoning Codes

The Fair Credit Report Act (section §605(a)(2)) requires lenders to reveal to their consumers, which factors adversely affected their credit score. Therefore, lenders need to know which factors affect a Fico score in order to be able to explain those factors to their consumers.

For this reason, Fico created a list of reasoning codes that credit issuers send along with a denial letter to their consumers, stating the reasons for which their credit score was adversely affected.

In the past, there were blogs that have put together lists of all the reasoning codes which consumers have received, and based on that, you were able to get an insight into which factors may adversely affect a credit score. Although this did not give you deep insight into the Fico scoring model, it did help you understand, more generally, which factors Fico will include in calculating the scoring model.

For a quick example, let’s use reasoning code number 10: “Ratio of Balances to Limit On Bank Revolving or Other Revolving Accounts Is too High”. This reasoning code tells you that your score was affected by high balances. It does not tell you, though, which ratio is considered a high balance. 20 percent? 50 percent? 100 percent?

The reasoning codes also only reveal factors that adversely affect credit scores, but there are still many factors that may affect your credit score, but possibly in a more minor way (which wouldn’t have been mentioned in a denial letter).

The Fico Scoring Model Is Confidential

The reason why Fico provides the reason codes is not in order to help a consumer understand their credit score. Fico provides it because the law requires them to do so. Credit reason codes are like the ingredients found in the back of a Coca-Cola bottle. Coca-Cola does not reveal to you the recipe of how to make coke, nor will the ingredients help you in any way figure out how to make coke. The ingredients are there only for legal reasons. (Some people believe that Coca Cola even adds some fake ingredients in order to confuse you!) The same is true about the reason codes. The reason codes do not in any way reveal to you how Fico calculates credit scores. It is just there to teach you a thing or two about the factors Fico may (or may not) use to determine your Fico score.

I will go through with you some major surprising things that we can find in the leaked document. I want you to keep in mind, that all the information found in that document needs to be taken with a grain of salt. I personally would not predict that Fico had written this document in order to educate consumers about the Fico scoring model. I would rather predict the opposite.

Reason Code #01: Amount Owed On Accounts Is Too High

The full description for this one is as follows: “Your Fico score considers how much you owe on your credit accounts such as credit cards and non-mortgage loans. Generally, the more you owe on these accounts the greater risk you post to lenders.”

What I found interesting is that it says any loan that is not a mortgage loan with a high balance will hurt your score. This will include loans that are installment loans, but not a mortgage loan. This is something new that I learned as I always thought that high utilization will only be effected by revolving loans and not by an installment loan.

The document goes further to explain that moving the debt from one account to another will usually not help your credit score. Please note that this does not refer to breaking up your balances between several credit cards and lowering the utilization since it’s a fact that it does help your Fico score. What Fico means to say is that moving the full balance from one account to another is not going to help your Fico score.  (This is a classic example of what we discussed, that Fico is looking to confuse consumers.)

You can read more about credit utilization here.

Fico Reason Code #06: Too Many Consumer Finance Company Loans

This confirms what we have already known, that taking out a loan from a consumer finance company may hurt your credit score.

Fico Reason Codes #14: Length of Time Accounts Has Been Established

In the full description, it says the following: “In your case, the age of your oldest account or the average age of your accounts is too short.”

Does fico calculate your score based on your average age of credit? I personally don’t think so. Read more about this here.

Fico Reason Code #08: Too Many Inquiries in Last 12 Months

This confirms what we have already known, that although credit inquiries stay on your credit report for 2 years, they will only affect your Fico score for up to 12 months.

Fico Reason Code #17: No Recent Non-Mortgage Balance Information

Here again, you can see that Fico counts mortgage loans separately, and not with all other installment loans.

Fico Reason Code #33: Proportion of Loan Balances to Loan Amount Is Too High

The full description here is: “Your Fico score weighs the balances of your mortgage and non-mortgage installment loans against the original loan amounts. In general, when you first obtain an installment loan your balances are high and as you pay the loan down your balances decreases.”

This is telling us, as we see in real life, that a new mortgage loan reported on your credit report can have a pretty significant hit on a Fico score for as much as a year.

Fico Reason #41: No Recent Retail Accounts

This confirms that having retail accounts such as store cards can help you have the proper credit mix.

Conclusion

Here in this post, we only went through some of the high lights of the leaked document which we found may interest our readers. If you’re interested to read the full document then please email me at sam@helpmebuildcredit.com and i will send it to you.

Have a great day!

Was this article helpful?

Sam Sam has nearly a decade's worth of experience educating his many readers on everything credit. Sam spends his days checking out credit cards for a full report, from the minute benefit details to the shebang of welcome bonuses. Plus studying the ins and outs of building proper credit. It’s his favorite pastime and he loves sharing it with others.

Leave A Comments

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2 Comments

  1. I’m 85. I relied on credit for many years and never had any credit problems. For the last 20 years or so I have not needed or used any credit. So now, my credit rating has been lowered only because there is “a lack of sufficient relevant information” regarding mortgage, auto and etc. credit accounts that I no longer have. Spectrum sent me a letter telling me that the terms they offered me may be less favorable than terms they offer to people with higher credit ratings. The lower credit ratings are given to some of us based not at all on any shortcomings in making timely credit payments, but based only on no longer using credit. In general, it is elderly retired people who are being penalized this way. I say it is arbitrary and capricious and shameful to do this to senior citizens. What say you?

    • Your 100 percent right. Many improvements need to be made to the scoring model system. But for you I would advise to get approved for at least one secured credit card so your credit file will still show activity even if you only use the card for a very minimum amount. You can find a list of secured cards here. Good luck

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Fico Reason Codes - Help Me Build Credit - […] week I posted about a leaked Fico document containing a list of all the Fico reason codes. I promised…
  2. Fico Reason Codes - What We Can Learn from Them - Help Me Build Credit - […] last few weeks I posted about a leaked Fico document revealing a full list of the Fico reason codes.…

Recent Posts

Follow us

Click here to subscribe to
our WhatsApp channel

Todays
best offers

Chase Ink Business Preferred

Earn 100,000 points after $15,000 spent within the first 3 months.

more info

British Airways Visa Signature Card

Earn a total of 100,000 points after $20,000 spent within the first year.

more info

Chase Sapphire Preferred

Earn 80,000 points after $4,000 spent within the first 3 months.

more info

Iberia Visa Signature Card

Earn a total of 100,000 points after $20,000 spent within the first year.

more info

You May Also Like

The 5 Most Important Factors In A FICO Score

The 5 Most Important Factors In A FICO Score

The FICO score model is the mostly widely used scoring model. As per Fico, as much as 90% of lending decisions that are done using a scoring model, use the Fico scoring model. In this post we will discuss the 5 most important factors that Fico would look at in order...

read more
The Best Websites to Monitor Your Credit Report For Free

The Best Websites to Monitor Your Credit Report For Free

In today’s day and age, we hear daily in the news of new hacks and new identity theft stories. By now everyone knows how important it is to properly monitor your credit report to make sure that no thieves are able to open any credit cards or loans on your name. There...

read more
Why Are My Credit Scores Different?

Why Are My Credit Scores Different?

When people check their credit score, should it be by Credit Karma or on their Discover statement, etc., they look at the three-digit number. They take it as a fact that this is their credit score. Period. The same way they know their age and weight, they feel that...

read more
Credit Scores And Mortgages: Here Is What You Need To Know

Credit Scores And Mortgages: Here Is What You Need To Know

Shopping for a mortgage but got bad credit? You are not alone! I invited a great mortgage expert Chaim Tarkieltaub from Mint Capital to explain the differences between the different mortgage products available for consumers at all stages of credit. Let's explore the...

read more
Intoducing FICO® Resilience Index

Intoducing FICO® Resilience Index

What is FICO® Resilience Index? Fico now has another tool to calculate how consumers use credit. The FICO® Resilience Index was created specifically for hard financial times. Lenders will be able to decide if a consumer can handle his finances during hard times. They...

read more
Getting Approved For A First Credit Card

Getting Approved For A First Credit Card

Credit is not something you are automatically born with. It is something you need to learn how to build on your own. The best way to build your credit is by getting approved for credit cards. But, hey! How do you get approved for credit cards without credit? Stay...

read more
Credit Utilization

Credit Utilization

One of the biggest factors that credit models look at when calculating a credit score is credit utilization. Credit utilization means how much of your credit line you utilize. The less money you spend on your credit cards, the less money you have in debt, compared to...

read more
Piggybacking Credit- Everything You Need to Know

Piggybacking Credit- Everything You Need to Know

What Is Piggybacking Credit? Piggybacking credit is having a third party, a creditworthy individual, add you to their credit card as an authorized user. This will allow you to receive the credit benefits from that account, helping you improve your own credit score...

read more
Does Closing A Credit Card Hurt Your Credit?

Does Closing A Credit Card Hurt Your Credit?

  People are always asking me: Does closing a credit card hurt your credit? Closing a credit card does not hurt your credit directly. But closing a credit card may hurt your credit indirectly. Confused? Let’s explain…   What Is Credit?   First, let’s go...

read more

Download link sent
succesfully

Got it *please check your promotional inbox

Error sending download link

Try Again